NEWS

Liquour bought as cops wait and store owner lies dying, inquiry reveals

16 Nov 2008
SHOCK revelations from the police internal review into the fatal shooting of liquor store owner Navtej Singh have left his already furious family with "serious concerns" about the police response to the horrific crime.

Navtej was gunned down during a raid on his liquor store on Riverton Road, Manurewa, on June 7. The 30-year-old died in Middlemore Hospital 27 hours later.

There was widespread outrage when it was later revealed police waited 26 minutes before allowing St John staff to enter the south Auckland store where Navtej lay fatally wounded on the floor.

His traumatised wife, Harjinder Kaur, his business partner and a close friend were in the store with a stricken Navtej, and a family spokesman told of how the terrified onlookers screamed for help.

But police still waited before entering the store and allowing ambulance officers to help Navtej even though customers had time to buy liquor during the wait.

Police and St John staff have defended the delay, saying it was an armed situation and best-practice procedures including waiting at a safe point had to be followed.

Detective Inspector Jim Gallagher said at the time police had to establish the gunman's whereabouts to ensure no one else's life was in danger.

But a source has told Sunday News the police internal review into the tragedy has revealed:

When one police car carrying weapons arrived at the Manurewa, south Auckland, scene, it was discovered the wrong keys had been taken to unlock the weapons cache. Officers had to wait for someone to rush back to the police station to get the correct keys.

An officer who was attending an aggravated robbery at the time of the call-out had to drop off a colleague and offender who were in his car to a police station before going to the fatal shooting scene.

Navtej's father, Nahar Singh, speaking through interpreter and New Zealand Sikh Society spokesman Manpreet Singh, yesterday told Sunday News he was angered by the revelations.

"(The) police really ... should have prepared themselves. If they forgot the key it is a serious concern," Nahar said.

"They shouldn't have forgotten the key, they should have prepared and everything should have been ready to come to the incident."

Tasman District Commander Superintendent Grant O'Fee, who wrote the internal police review, declined to comment on the source's revelations to Sunday News.

"The report has not yet been released publicly, so until such time as the commissioner wishes to do that I'm not really at liberty to discuss it," O'Fee said.

Police National Headquarters also declined to comment, as a review of police conduct and procedures during the incident by the Independent Police Conduct Authority is still not complete.

"Out of courtesy to the authority and their complainants, we would not release an internal debrief document ahead of the authority's deliberations," a spokeswoman said in a statement.

Navtej's family announced last month they had laid an official complaint with the IPCA. The review is expected to be completed in a few weeks.
27 Dec 2008 - Woman subjected to 'brutal' sex attack on Christmas Day
NZ Herald ... [more]
27 Dec 2008 - Heartless thieves add insult to misery
By Alanah May Eriksen - NZ Herald ... [more]
15 Dec 2008 - Opotiki locals told to break silence over killing
NZ Herald ... [more]
15 Dec 2008 - 2000 complaints over police
EMILY WATT - The Dominion Post | Monday, 15 December 2008 ... [more]
14 Dec 2008 - Mother's hate for son's killer
Carolyne Meng-Yee - NZ Herald ... [more]
14 Dec 2008 - Enough P for all Auckland
Carolyne Meng-Yee - NZ Herald ... [more]
14 Dec 2008 - Wheel clamping scam targets Asian women
4:00AM Sunday Dec 14, 2008, Rebecca Lewis ... [more]
12 Dec 2008 - Robber spoke Hindi as held knife to toddler
NZ HERALD STAFF & NZPA ... [more]
12 Dec 2008 - Neighbourhood Support Auckland News List
Here is the latest Newsletter! ... [more]
27 Nov 2008 - Low And Behold - Meet Peter Low
Edward Rooney - The Aucklander ... [more]
21 Nov 2008 - Staff members arrested over supermarket robbery
NZ Herald ... [more]
16 Nov 2008 - Liquour bought as cops wait and store owner lies dying, inquiry reveals
TAMMY BUCKLEY - Sunday News ... [more]
03 Nov 2008 - Asians dispute Labour's 'don't fret' message on law and order
After the murders of three Asian people in the space of nine days this year, many in the community are finding the message hard to swallow. ... [more]
28 Oct 2008 - Law and order: Asians to meet candidates
A SECOND Manukau Asian Forum meeting takes place this Thursday and will be attended by political party candidates speaking on public safety issues. ... [more]
23 Oct 2008 - Pledge for more police applauded
A NATIONAL Party pledge to put 300 more police officers on the Counties Manukau beat by the end of 2010 is music to the ears of its Botany candidate Pansy Wong. ... [more]
23 Oct 2008 - Public help find bank getaway car
THE police are saying a “big thanks” to Highland Park residents who helped find the stolen vehicle used as a getaway car in last Friday’s bank theft in Highland Park. ... [more]
08 Oct 2008 - Warm weather makes it burglary time again
HOWICK police investigators were busy with household burglaries last weekend and they’re warning residents to be vigilant and security conscious as the warmer whether begins. ... [more]
24 Sep 2008 - Law and order main priority - Howick and Botany Times
HOWICK and Pakuranga residents are concerned about crime, policing, gangs, personal safety and graffiti, says Manukau City councillor Dick Quax. ... [more]
07 Sep 2008 - Sunday Program: Sep 7, 2008
Clean, Green, And Violent ... [more]
11 Aug 2008 - TV 1“ Sunday” 栏目组拍摄Peter Low 教女性自我防卫
TV 1“ Sunday” 栏目组拍摄Peter Low 教女性自我防卫 ... [more]
08 Aug 2008 - Robbers winning in crime hotspot
New Zealand Herald ... [more]
08 Aug 2008 - Dairy-owner 'had to shoot' to save lives
New Zealand Herald ... [more]
04 Aug 2008 - Manurewa 毛利會堂文化交流活動後記
毛利會堂文化交流活動後記 ... [more]
04 Aug 2008 - Food gang foiled in grocery grab
Howick and Pakuranga Times ... [more]
03 Aug 2008 - Hui meeting for at Manurewa Marae
Community leaders in Manukau are banding together to tackle the growing problem of violence and crime in their city ... [more]
05 Jul 2008 - 15000 Protest March - News Video Clips & Photos
One News , and 3 News ... [more]
25 Jun 2008 - Give police power to attack gangs - O'Connor
By Alan Williams - NZPA ... [more]
24 Jun 2008 - Clampdown on liquor sales looms
By Claire Trevett - NZ Herald ... [more]
20 Jun 2008 - Detectives talk to slain woman's son, 8
The hunt for people who fatally drove over Joanne Wang after snatching her handbag in a Manukau carpark continued yesterday - but police say they have no real suspects at this stage. ... [more]
19 Jun 2008 - Parliament passes anti-tagging law
A bill that gets tough with taggers has been passed by Parliament with an overwhelming majority ... [more]
19 Jun 2008 - Angry Asian community demands tougher penalties
AFTER three murders of Indian and Asian people over 10 days, Manukau’s Asian community is distraught at the level of violence and demanding heavier penalties on crime. ... [more]
18 Jun 2008 - [Mayor] Troup urges calm in Manukau
THE Manukau community needs to come together and be united in an ongoing response to recent violence, says acting Mayor Gary Troup. ... [more]
16 Jun 2008 - Crime out of control, say fed-up marchers
Four-year-old Edouard talks as if his brother Augustine, who was murdered last year, is still alive - and his dad Charlie Borrell thinks it's a blessing. ... [more]
20 Mar 2008 - NZ's poor violent crime rating 'no surprise'
New Zealand is perceived correctly as a place with high levels of violent crime, Sensible Sentencing Trust spokesman Garth McVicar said after New Zealand scored highly an international crime survey. ... [more]

MEMBER LOGIN

Member ID
password
Asian Anti-crime Group (AAG), Fax: 09-272-9047, Website: www.aag.org.nz
Postal address: PO Box 64-130, Botany Town Centre, Auckland 2016
Disclaimer / Copyright - Copyright © 2008 Asian Anti-Crime Group (AAG) New Zealand